We’re in your neighborhood FISHERS
Call now! we're here 24/7


More Less
Expires on: 04/30/2024

Fishers Water Heater Replacement

fishers plumbing repair

Replacing A Hot Water Heater: Your Ultimate Guide

Every homeowner in Fishers, Indiana, knows the importance of a reliable water heater. It keeps you warm with comforting showers, helps with cleaning dishes, and is essential for countless daily tasks. But like any appliance, water heaters don’t last forever. So, when the time comes to replace yours, what do you need to know? Worry not, this guide will walk you through the process, step-by-step.

Signs It’s Time for a New Water Heater:

  • Age: Most water heaters last around 8-110 years. If yours is approaching this age and experiencing issues, consider a replacement.
  • Decreased hot water: Is your shower lukewarm or taking longer to heat up? This could signify a failing heating element or sediment buildup.
  • Leaks: Leaks around the tank are a red flag and can cause significant water damage. Don’t delay addressing this issue. This will almost always require replacement.
  • Rusty water: Rusty water indicates corrosion in the tank, posing health risks and requiring immediate replacement.

Choosing the Right Water Heater:

When selecting a new water heater, consider these factors:

  • Size: Choose a size that meets your household’s hot water needs.
  • Fuel type: Options include gas, electric, or tankless water heaters, each with its advantages and costs.
  • Energy efficiency: Look for Energy Star-certified models to save on energy bills.

The Replacement Process:

Replacing a water heater can be complex and involves plumbing expertise. For safety and a smooth installation, consider hiring Mister Quik in Fishers. They’ll handle the following:

  • Disconnecting the old water heater: This involves shutting off the water supply, draining the tank, and disconnecting gas or electrical lines (depending on the fuel type).
  • Installing the new water heater: This includes connecting the unit to water and gas/electrical lines, ensuring proper venting, and checking for leaks.
  • Testing and finalizing: The plumber will test the water heater for functionality, adjust temperature settings, and ensure everything is working properly.
  • Hauling away the old equipment: Our team will haul away your old equipment to be disposed of, leaving you worry-free. 

Remember: While this guide provides an overview, replacing a water heater is best left to a qualified plumber. They possess the expertise and tools to ensure a safe and efficient installation, keeping your home with hot water for years to come.



Brands We Work With

When To Replace Your Water Heater?

Everyone in Fishers loves a steaming hot shower, but what happens when the hot water sputters or disappears entirely? It might be time to consider a water heater replacement.

Signs Your Water Heater Needs Replacing:

Gas Icon

Most water heaters last 8 - 10 years. If yours is older, it's nearing the end of its lifespan.

Broken Icon
No Hot Water

This is the most obvious sign.

Troubles Icon
Lukewarm Water

Even if you have some hot water, it might not be enough for your needs.

Gas Icon

Leaks can indicate internal damage and potential safety hazards.

Broken Icon
Rumbling Noises

Strange noises coming from your water heater can signal trouble.

Troubles Icon
Rusty Water

This indicates rust buildup inside the tank, affecting water quality and efficiency.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the manufacturer’s suggested service life, the average life expectancy of a water heater is about 8 to 10 years. That varies with the unit’s location and design, installation quality, maintenance schedule, and water quality.

A water heater making strange noises indicates that the unit is beginning to fail. These sounds may include popping, banging, sizzling or even rumbling. Water heater noises are usually caused by sediment build-up on the bottom of the tank. When this happens, it can cause the unit to overheat and eventually fail.


If you suspect your water heater is over 10 years old, consider replacing it before you’re left with an emergency decision. To determine the age of your water heater, you’ll need to identify the Brand Name and Serial Number of your unit.

With proper maintenance, a tank water heater tank should last 8-10 years. A tankless water heater can last for 15 years +.

It would be wise to start looking for a replacement because, like all mechanical equipment, water heaters have a life expectancy. Traditional storage water heaters typically last about 10 years, while tankless water heaters can last 15 years or more.

Tools You'll Need When Replacing A Hot Water Heater

Thinking about tackling a water heater replacement yourself in Fishers? While it’s certainly possible for some DIY enthusiasts, it’s important to be well-prepared before diving in. Here’s a breakdown of the essential tools and supplies you’ll need to get the job done:

Kitchen Sink Installation Fishers

Safety First:

  • Safety glasses: Protect your eyes from splashes and debris.
  • Work gloves: Shield your hands from cuts and burns.
  • Respirator: Useful when dealing with dust or potential fumes (consult the water heater manual for specific recommendations).

Essential Tools:

  • Adjustable wrenches: For loosening and tightening various nuts and bolts.
  • Channel locks: Grip and turn stubborn fittings or pipes.
  • Socket wrench set: Needed for specific nuts and bolts with different head shapes.
  • Tape measure: Measure pipe lengths and clearances.
  • Level: Ensure your new water heater is properly positioned.
  • Utility knife: Cut hoses or insulation as needed (be cautious!).
  • Putty knife: Remove old sealant and prep surfaces for new application.


  • New water heater: Choose the right size and type for your needs (consult a plumber if unsure).
  • Flexible water heater hoses: Connect the water heater to your existing plumbing.
  • Shutoff valves: This allows you to isolate the water supply for easier installation.
  • Teflon tape: Creates a watertight seal on pipe threads.
  • Pipe dope: Another option for sealing pipe threads, often used for gas connections.
  • Safety pan: Catches any drips or leaks during the process.

Remember: This list serves as a general guide, and specific requirements may vary depending on your water heater model and existing plumbing setup. If you’re unsure about any part of the process, it’s always best to consult Mister Quik Home Services for professional assistance and ensure a safe and successful water heater replacement.

Tips And Tricks For Replacing A Hot Water Heater

Hot water is like the silent hero of our homes, keeping us warm in showers and powering dishwashers. But what happens when your trusty water heater starts acting up? Don’t panic! Replacing a water heater might seem daunting, but with these simple tips, you can approach the project with confidence, whether you choose to tackle it yourself or hire a professional plumber in Fishers.

Electricity Icon
Diagnose the Problem

Before diving in, confirm a replacement is truly needed. Is your water heater leaking, making strange noises, or struggling to maintain hot water? If so, a replacement might be the best solution.

Water Icon
Research Your Options

Water heaters come in various sizes, fuel types (gas or electric), and efficiencies. Consider your hot water needs, budget, and available space when choosing a new model.

Gas Icon
Safety First

Turn off the water supply and gas valve (if applicable) before starting any work. If you're not comfortable with electrical or plumbing tasks, hiring Mister Quik is highly recommended.

Gas Icon
Gather the Tools

Replacing a water heater requires specific tools like wrenches, screwdrivers, and pipe wrenches. Make sure you have everything you need before starting.

How Do You Replace A Water Heater?

Cold showers? Lukewarm laundry? These are all signs that your trusty water heater might be nearing the end of its journey. Replacing a water heater might seem like a daunting task, but with the right information and approach, it can be a smooth and manageable process. This guide will walk you through the steps involved in replacing your water heater in Fishers, Indiana.

Signs You Need a Water Heater Replacement:

Before diving into the replacement process, it’s important to identify if a replacement is truly necessary. Here are some telltale signs:

Age: Most water heaters have a lifespan of 8 – 10 years. If yours is approaching or exceeding this age, it’s wise to consider a replacement.

Lack of hot water: This is the most obvious sign and can be caused by various factors like a failing heating element or a faulty thermostat.

Leaking: Leaks around the water heater base indicate a potential breach in the tank, which requires immediate replacement to prevent further damage.

Rusty water: This signifies internal corrosion, compromising water quality and potentially leading to premature failure.

Odd noises: Unusual banging or knocking sounds coming from the water heater can indicate internal problems needing professional attention.

Fishers Water Heater Replacement Cost

Needing a water heater replacement can be unexpected and bring up questions about cost. In Fishers, Indiana, the average cost to replace a water heater falls between $3,000 -$ 5,000. However, the final price can vary depending on several factors, which we’ll explore in this guide.

Factors Affecting Water Heater Replacement Cost:

Water Heater Type

Gas water heaters: Generally more affordable than electric models upfront, but gas line installation or extension can add costs. Electric water heaters: Usually have lower initial costs, but electricity rates can impact long-term running expenses. Tankless water heaters: Most expensive option upfront, but offers energy efficiency and continuous hot water supply, potentially saving you money in the long run.

Water Heater Size

Larger water heaters, needed for bigger households, usually cost more than smaller models.

Labor Costs

Plumber rates can vary depending on their experience, company overhead, and the complexity of the installation. Additional Considerations: Removal and disposal of the old water heater: Some companies may include this in their quote, while others might charge extra. Permits and inspections: Required in most areas, and the cost can vary.

Tips for Managing Water Heater Replacement Costs

Consider the long-term: While upfront costs might influence your initial decision, factor in the water heater's efficiency and lifespan when comparing options. Ask about warranties: A good warranty can provide peace of mind and cover future repairs. Explore financing options: Some companies or financing institutions might offer payment plans to make the cost more manageable.

Remember: This is just a general guide, and the actual cost for your water heater replacement in Fishers might differ. It’s crucial to consult with licensed and insured plumbers in your area to get accurate estimates based on your specific needs and situation.



Troubleshoot Checklist:

Check for Warning Signs:
  • No hot water or lukewarm water: This could indicate a failing heating element, thermostat, or sediment buildup.
  • Leaking water: Leaks can occur from the tank, pressure relief valve, or connections. This requires immediate attention to prevent water damage.
Consider Age and Efficiency:
  • Age: Water heaters typically last 8-10 years. If yours is approaching this age, consider replacement to avoid potential problems.
  • Efficiency: Older water heaters are less efficient. Upgrading to a newer, high-efficiency model can save you money on energy bills in the long run.
Evaluate Your Needs:
  • Size: Consider the number of people in your household and hot water usage to determine the appropriate size for your needs.
  • Fuel Type: Choose between gas or electric water heaters based on your existing infrastructure, cost considerations, and energy efficiency preferences.
Gather Information & Quotes:
  • Research water heater types, features, and efficiency ratings.
  • Contact licensed plumbers in your area for estimates, considering factors like labor costs and permit requirements.
Make an Informed Decision:
  • Compare quotes and consider factors beyond just price, such as experience, warranties, and customer reviews.
  • Choose a qualified plumber who explains the process, costs, and your options clearly


Schedule On Your Own Without Making a Call. Click to Get Started!

New to The Area? Check Out These Locations For Some Fun This Weekend!
Schoolhouse 7 Cafe
Taylor’s Bakery
Cheeney Creek Natural Area